Effect of Recycled Aggregate on the Compressive and Tensile Strength of Concrete

  Share :          
  100

1. Introduction The expansion of urban development and the increasing number of construction and demolition projects have led to a significant rise in construction waste. This has encouraged researchers to investigate the possibility of reusing such waste in the production of sustainable construction materials. Recycled aggregate is considered one of the most promising materials for concrete production. It is generally obtained by crushing and processing waste concrete to produce aggregate that can partially or completely replace natural aggregate. Compressive and tensile strengths are among the most important indicators used to evaluate the mechanical performance of concrete. Therefore, investigating the effect of recycled aggregate on these two properties is essential for determining its suitability for use in concrete structures while achieving environmental and economic benefits by reducing the consumption of natural resources and minimizing construction waste. 2. Concept of Recycled Aggregate Recycled aggregate is a granular material obtained from the processing of construction and demolition waste, particularly hardened concrete. The production process generally involves crushing, screening, and cleaning to remove impurities and undesirable materials. Recycled aggregate is characterized by the presence of adhered residual old cement mortar on the surfaces of its particles. This makes its physical and mechanical properties different from those of natural aggregate. Its main characteristics include: High water absorption: Due to the porous nature of the old cement mortar attached to the aggregate particles. Lower specific gravity: Compared with natural aggregate in many cases. Variable abrasion resistance: Depending on the quality of the original concrete and the crushing and processing methods. Variable particle-size distribution: As a result of differences in waste sources and screening processes. These characteristics directly or indirectly influence the workability and mechanical strength of concrete. 3. Effect of Recycled Aggregate on Compressive Strength Compressive strength is one of the most important mechanical properties of concrete, as it represents the ability of concrete to withstand compressive loads before failure occurs. When recycled aggregate is used to replace natural aggregate, compressive strength may decrease, particularly at higher replacement percentages. This reduction can be attributed to several factors, including: First: Old Cement Mortar Recycled aggregate particles contain adhered old cement mortar, which may have relatively high porosity and lower strength than natural aggregate. This can create weaker zones within the newly produced concrete. Second: Interfacial Transition Zone An interfacial transition zone (ITZ) develops between the aggregate and the cement paste. When recycled aggregate is used, additional interfacial zones may form due to the presence of both the old mortar surface and the original aggregate surface. This may increase the possibility of crack formation and reduce bonding strength. Third: High Water Absorption Recycled aggregate generally absorbs more water than natural aggregate. If the mixing water content is not properly adjusted, the effective water-to-cement ratio may change, consequently affecting the compressive strength of concrete. Fourth: Replacement Percentage Increasing the replacement percentage of natural aggregate with recycled aggregate generally leads to a reduction in compressive strength. However, the extent of this reduction depends on aggregate quality, the properties of the original concrete, the water-to-cement ratio, and curing conditions. 4. Effect of Recycled Aggregate on Tensile Strength Tensile strength is another important property of concrete, although concrete has considerably lower tensile strength than compressive strength. This property helps evaluate the ability of concrete to resist cracking caused by tensile stresses. Tensile strength can be evaluated using the splitting tensile strength test, which is commonly performed on cylindrical concrete specimens. The use of recycled aggregate may lead to a reduction in tensile strength due to several factors, including: Weak bonding between recycled aggregate and the new cement paste. The presence of microcracks and pores in the residual old mortar. Increased water absorption, which may alter mixing and curing conditions. A higher possibility of crack propagation through weak interfacial transition zones. On the other hand, improving the quality of recycled aggregate and applying suitable pretreatment methods can reduce these effects and enhance the bonding between the concrete constituents. 5. Factors Affecting the Strength of Concrete Containing Recycled Aggregate The compressive and tensile strengths of concrete are influenced by several factors that should be considered during concrete mix design. The most important factors include: Replacement Percentage: The proportion of recycled aggregate used instead of natural aggregate affects the final strength of concrete. Aggregate Source: Aggregate properties vary depending on the type, strength, and previous exposure conditions of the original concrete. Particle Size and Grading: Proper particle-size distribution helps reduce voids and improve the packing of concrete constituents. Water-to-Cement Ratio: This factor directly influences the porosity of the cement paste and the strength of concrete. Pretreatment Methods: Cleaning, washing, water treatment, and removing part of the adhered old mortar may improve recycled aggregate quality. Curing Conditions: Curing duration, temperature, and moisture conditions influence the development of concrete strength over time. 6. Proposed Experimental Program The effect of recycled aggregate on compressive and tensile strengths can be evaluated through a laboratory experimental program involving several concrete mixtures with different replacement percentages of natural aggregate. Five concrete mixtures are proposed. The first mixture serves as the control mixture and contains 100% natural aggregate, while the remaining mixtures contain recycled aggregate replacement percentages of 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100%. The cement content, target particle-size distribution, and water-to-cement ratio should be kept as consistent as possible. The water absorption of recycled aggregate should also be measured, and the mixing conditions should be adjusted according to its moisture condition to ensure reliable comparisons between the mixtures. The proposed laboratory tests include: First: Slump Test This test is used to determine the workability of fresh concrete and investigate the influence of recycled aggregate on the consistency and ease of placing and compacting the concrete mixture. Second: Compressive Strength Test Concrete cubes or cylinders are prepared and tested using a compression testing machine to determine the maximum stress sustained by each specimen before failure. Third: Splitting Tensile Strength Test This test is performed on cylindrical specimens to indirectly determine the tensile strength of concrete and evaluate the effect of different replacement percentages on its cracking behaviour. Fourth: Water Absorption Test This test helps determine the porosity of concrete and assess how its water absorption behaviour is affected by the properties of recycled aggregate. It is recommended that the strength tests be conducted after curing periods of 7, 28, and 56 days to monitor strength development over time and compare the performance of the different concrete mixtures. 7. Expected Results and Discussion The study is expected to reveal differences in compressive and tensile strengths between the control mixture and the mixtures containing recycled aggregate. The reduction in strength may become more pronounced as the replacement percentage increases, particularly when low-quality recycled aggregate containing large amounts of adhered old cement mortar is used. However, this reduction is not constant in all cases. Some concrete mixtures may achieve acceptable strength when high-quality recycled aggregate is used, provided that the water-to-cement ratio is properly controlled, particle-size distribution is improved, and suitable aggregate treatment methods are applied. Comparing the compressive and tensile strength results will help identify the replacement percentage that provides an appropriate balance between mechanical performance and environmental sustainability. 8. Conclusions The use of recycled aggregate in concrete production represents a promising approach to reducing natural aggregate consumption and reusing construction and demolition waste. However, its effect on compressive and tensile strengths depends on aggregate quality, replacement percentage, concrete mix properties, and curing conditions. Furthermore, pretreating recycled aggregate, controlling its water absorption, improving particle-size distribution, and selecting appropriate replacement percentages can contribute to enhancing the performance of concrete containing recycled aggregate. Therefore, conducting laboratory investigations is essential for determining the suitability of recycled aggregate for different structural applications and achieving a balance between engineering requirements and environmental and economic objectives.