Seismic Protection of Precast Concrete Structures Using Yielding C-Shaped Dampers (C-devices)

05/11/2026   Share :        
133  

Prepared by Dr. Oday Al-Mamoori, Department of Civil Engineering, Al-Mustaqbal University Precast concrete structures are a common structural system in industrial and commercial buildings, valued for their speed of construction and quality control. However, their performance under strong seismic loads is a concern, since energy dissipation in them often relies on plastic deformations at column bases alone. Studies have shown that these regions cannot be relied upon under repeated cyclic loading, owing to the gradual degradation of strength and P-Delta effects, which may lead to local failure of the columns. Such frames therefore require special attention to ensure adequate resistance. The retrofit concept is based on adding high-efficiency hysteretic energy dissipation dampers (HEDDs) locally around the beam-to-column joints, with minimal intrusion into the structural space. The C-shaped damper is fabricated from a steel plate in the form of a rectangular frame, with circular transitions at the inner corners to avoid stress concentration and to control the extent of the energy-dissipating zone. The damper’s arms and the connecting plate assembly remain in the elastic range, while plastic deformations are concentrated in the dissipating zone, which makes it easy to inspect the damper and replace it after an earthquake. Previous studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of these dampers as an additional source of energy dissipation; however, detailed analytical studies on modeling them have been limited. Hence this study of the effect of the length of the dissipating zone and the radius of the circular transition on the damper’s monotonic response, using finite element models and a nonlinear fiber-based approach in SAP2000. The results showed that these two parameters are among the most influential factors affecting the damper’s load-bearing capacity and the spread of the plastic zone within it. On the numerical analysis side, a methodology was developed to calibrate equivalent nonlinear springs that simulate the expected hysteretic behavior of the damper under monotonic and reversed cyclic loading, and they showed good agreement with the detailed models. The “Limit of Efficient Damper Strength” (LEDS) was also derived to ensure that the dampers are activated before an undesirable collapse mechanism forms, so that plastic hinges form at the column bases only. The original and retrofitted frames were subjected to nonlinear time-history analyses using natural earthquake records scaled to three levels of seismic intensity. The results showed that dampers calibrated with a strength equal to half of the LEDS reduced the mean drift ratio by approximately 27%, 30%, and 30% for the low, medium, and high intensity levels, respectively. The mean residual displacement also decreased by approximately 47% and 40% at the low and high levels, and rotation in the critical regions of the columns fell by more than 48%. In contrast, the base shear force recorded a moderate increase, of less than 48% at the medium and high levels, and remained within the shear capacity of the sections. The mean displacement demand-to-capacity ratio in the structures fitted with the devices was less than 1.0 at the high level, whereas it exceeded 1.0 in the original structure (without the device). The research also addressed the modeling of the beam-to-column joints using a two-dimensional model that accounts for friction and slip at the contact interface, which gave a reasonable approximation of the relative displacements and of the dissipation of part of the seismic energy in the frictional joint. Experimental verification is still needed. This technique thus represents an engineering solution that combines seismic efficiency, limited structural intervention, and economic feasibility, making it an important option for retrofitting precast concrete structures. Source: Oday Hamzah Hammood Al-Mamoori. Seismic Redesign of Precast Portal RC Frames using Yield C-devices. PhD Thesis, Civil Engineering Department, University of Brighton, United Kingdom, April 2019, Chapter 5.